Ympäristön, kansanterveyden ja elintarvikkeiden turvallisuuden valiokunta

Transkriptio

1 EUROOPAN PARLAMENTTI Ympäristön, kansanterveyden ja elintarvikkeiden turvallisuuden valiokunta ENVI_PV(2012)1128_1 PÖYTÄKIRJA Kokous 28. marraskuuta 2012 klo ja ja 29. marraskuuta 2012 klo ja BRYSSEL Kokoushuone: József Antall (4Q2) Puheenjohtaja Matthias Groote avasi kokouksen keskiviikkona 28. marraskuuta 2012 klo Esityslistan hyväksyminen ENVI_OJ (2012)1128v01-00 Esityslista hyväksyttiin sellaisena kuin se on esitettynä tässä pöytäkirjassa. 2. Puheenjohtajan ilmoitukset 2.1. Tulkkaustilanne Tulkkaus oli saatavilla kaikilla muilla paitsi viron ja maltan kielillä (myös kroatian kielellä), mikä vastaa valiokunnan tavanomaista kielivalikoimaa Tulossa oleva seminaari Työpaja "terveystaloudesta" terveyttä käsittelevän työryhmän yhteispuheenjohtajien Glenis Willmottin ja Alojz Peterlen kanssa keskiviikkona 28. marraskuuta 2012 klo , kokoushuone PHS P7C Kokoukseen osallistuvat vierailijaryhmät Kahdeksan toimittajan ryhmä osallistui kokoukseen 28. marraskuuta klo , Jolanta Hibnerin toimiston järjestämä vierailu. Bas Eickhoutin kutsuma ryhmä ympäristötieteen 3. ja 4. vuosikurssin (koko- ja osapäiväisiä) opiskelijoita ja opettaja, Van Hall Larenstein, University of Applied Sciences, Leeuwarden (Alankomaat). PV\ doc PE v01-00 Moninaisuudessaan yhtenäinen

2 10 harjoittelijaa terveys- ja kuluttaja-asioiden pääosastosta osallistui kokoukseen torstaina 29. marraskuuta Keskustelukutsu Suhteista Etelä-Aasian maihin vastaavan valtuuskunnan puheenjohtaja Jean Lambert kutsui kiinnostuneet ENVI-valiokunnan jäsenet osallistumaan YK:n ilmastonmuutoskonferenssiin COP18 (Doha), jossa keskustellaan Etelä-Aasian maihin kohdistuvista odotuksista ja painopisteistä. 3. Pöytäkirjan hyväksyminen: Ei ollut. 4. CITES-sopimuksen osapuolten 16. konferenssin valmistelu ENVI/7/ /2838(RSP) Yhteisesittelijä(t): Vastaava: ENVI Esther de Lange (PPE) Bas Eickhout (Verts/ALE) Gerben-Jan Gerbrandy (ALDE) Anna Rosbach (ECR) Kartika Tamara Liotard (GUE/NGL) Karin Kadenbach (S&D) Päätöslauselmaesitysluonnoksen käsittely Suullisesti vastattavien kysymysten hyväksyminen Tarkistusten jättämisen määräaika: 30. marraskuuta 2012 klo Puheenvuorot: Matthias Groote, John Scanlon (CITESin pääsihteeri), Richard Seeber (Esther de Langen puolesta), Karin Kadenbach, Gerben-Jan Gerbrandy, Bas Eickhout, Peter van Dalen, Carl Schlyter, Hans Stielstra (ympäristöasioiden pääosasto) Päätös: Suullinen kysymys hyväksyttiin (äänin 43 puolesta, 1 vastaan ja 1 tyhjä). Aikataulu: Tarkistusten jättämisen määräaika: 30. marraskuuta 2012 klo Alusten kierrätys (yhdessä kohdan 6 kanssa) ENVI/7/09192 ***I 2012/0055(COD) COM (2012)0118 C7-0082/2012 Mietintöluonnoksen käsittely Tarkistusten jättämisen määräaika: 5. joulukuuta 2012 klo Esittelijä: Carl Schlyter (Verts/ALE) PR PE v02-00 PE v /110 PV\ doc

3 Vastaava: Lausunto: ENVI ITRE, TRAN, JURI Puheenvuorot: (Katso kohta 6) Aikataulu: Tarkistusten jättämisen määräaika: 30. marraskuuta 2012 klo Ehdotus neuvoston päätökseksi jäsenvaltioiden velvoittamisesta ratifioimaan vuonna 2009 tehty alusten turvallista ja ympäristön kannalta asianmukaista kierrätystä koskeva Hongkongin kansainvälinen yleissopimus tai liittymään siihen Euroopan unionin edun mukaisesti (yhdessä kohdan 5 kanssa) ENVI/7/09188 *** 2012/0056(NLE) COM (2012)0120 Keskustelu Esittelijä: Vastaava: Lausunto: Carl Schlyter (Verts/ALE) ENVI ITRE, TRAN, JURI Puheenvuorot (kohdat 5 ja 6): Matthias Groote, Soledad Blanco (ympäristöasioiden pääosasto), Carl Schlyter, Christofer Fjellner, Vittorio Prodi, Chris Davies, Peter van Dalen, Sabine Wils, Linda McAvan, Nikos Chrysogelos, Richard Seeber, Karl-Heinz Florenz, Theodoros Skylakakis Aikataulu: Tarkistusten jättämisen määräaika: 5. joulukuuta 2012 klo Enemmän hyötyä irti EU:n ympäristötoimenpiteistä: luottamuksen lisääminen parantamalla tietämystä ja reagointia ENVI/7/ /2104(INI) Mietintöluonnoksen käsittely COM(2012)0095 Esittelijä: Oreste Rossi (EFD) PR PE v02-00 Vastaava: ENVI Lausunto: ITRE, TRAN, REGI, JURI, PETI Puheenvuorot: Matthias Groote, Oreste Rossi, Karl-Heinz Florenz, Jo Leinen, Theodoros Skylakakis, Christa Klaß, Liam Cashman (ympäristöasioiden pääosasto) 8. Ehdotettujen toimenpiteiden vastustaminen työjärjestyksen 88 artiklan 2 kohdan mukaisesti: Maitohapon käyttö naudanruhojen mikrobiologisen pintakontaminaation vähentämiseen ENVI/7/10918 PV\ doc 3/110 PE v01-00

4 2012/2840(RPS) COM (2012)0578 Päätöslauselmaesitysluonnoksen käsittely RE PE v01-00 Vastaava: ENVI Puheenvuorot: Matthias Groote, Linda McAvan, Dagmar Roth-Behrendt, Carl Schlyter, Renate Sommer, Corinne Lepage, Peter Liese, Mairead McGuinness, Chris Davies, Sophie Auconie, Erik Bánki, Bernard van Goethem (terveys- ja kuluttajaasioiden pääosasto), Jean-Luc Demarty (kauppapolitiikan pääosasto) * Kokous keskeytettiin klo 12.40, ja sitä jatkettiin klo puheenjohtaja Matthias Grooten johdolla. *** 9. Ehdotettujen toimenpiteiden vastustaminen työjärjestyksen 88 artiklan 2 kohdan mukaisesti: Maitohapon käyttö naudanruhojen mikrobiologisen pintakontaminaation vähentämiseen ENVI/7/ /2840(RPS) COM (2012)0578 Vastaava: ENVI Päätöslauselmaesityksen hyväksyminen Päätös: (Ks. äänestystulokset liitteessä II.) Päätöslauselmaesitysluonnos hylättiin (äänin 22 puolesta, 25 vastaan ja 0 tyhjää). 10. Vaarallisten valmisteiden luokitus, pakkaaminen ja merkinnät ENVI/7/08689 ***I 2012/0007(COD) COM (2012)0008 C7-0021/2012 Esittelijä: Eija-Riitta Korhola (PPE) PR PE v01-00 AM PE v01-00 Vastaava: ENVI Lausunto: JURI rancesco Enrico Speroni (EFD) Mietintöluonnoksen hyväksyminen Päätös: (Ks. äänestystulokset liitteessä III.) Mietintöluonnos hyväksyttiin näin muutettuna (äänin 53 puolesta, 0 vastaan ja 0 tyhjää). Lainsäädäntöpäätöslauselmaluonnos hyväksyttiin (äänin 51 puolesta, 0 vastaan ja 0 tyhjää). PE v /110 PV\ doc

5 11. Unionin pelastuspalvelumekanismi ENVI/7/08551 ***I 2011/0461(COD) COM (2011)0934 C7-0519/2011 Esittelijä: Elisabetta Gardini (PPE) PR PE v01-00 AM PE v03-00 AM PE v03-00 Vastaava: ENVI* Lausunto: AFET Ioan Mircea Paşcu (S&D) PA PE v01-00 AM PE v01-00 DEVE* Michèle Striffler (PPE) AD PE v03-00 AM PE v01-00 BUDG Georgios Stavrakakis (S&D) AD PE v02-00 AM PE v01-00 REGI Oldřich Vlasák (ECR) AD PE v02-00 AM PE v01-00 Mietintöluonnoksen hyväksyminen Päätös: (Ks. äänestystulokset liitteessä IV.) Mietintöluonnos hyväksyttiin näin muutettuna (äänin 52 puolesta, 5 vastaan ja 3 tyhjää). Lainsäädäntöpäätöslauselmaluonnos hyväksyttiin (äänin 52 puolesta, 5 vastaan ja 3 tyhjää). Päätös aloittaa neuvottelut hyväksyttiin. 12. Vesipolitiikan alan prioriteettiaineet ENVI/7/08744 ***I 2011/0429(COD) COM (2011)0876 C7-0026/2012 Esittelijä: Vastaava: ENVI Lausunto: Richard Seeber (PPE) PR PE v01-00 AM PE v04-00 AM PE v04-00 AM PE v01-00 ITRE Päätös: ei lausuntoa AGRI Päätös: ei lausuntoa PECH Päätös: ei lausuntoa Mietintöluonnoksen hyväksyminen Päätös: (Ks. äänestystulokset liitteessä V.) Mietintöluonnos hyväksyttiin näin muutettuna (äänin 46 puolesta, 7 vastaan ja 6 tyhjää). Lainsäädäntöpäätöslauselmaluonnos hyväksyttiin (äänin 43 puolesta, 7 vastaan ja 8 tyhjää). Päätös aloittaa neuvottelut hyväksyttiin (äänin 44 puolesta, 7 vastaan ja 2 tyhjää). PV\ doc 5/110 PE v01-00

6 13. Euroopan meri- ja kalatalousrahasto (neuvoston asetuksen (EY) N:o 1198/2006 ja neuvoston asetuksen (EY) N:o 861/2006 sekä yhdennetystä meripolitiikasta annetun neuvoston asetuksen N:o XXX/2011 kumoaminen) ENVI/7/08043 ***I 2011/0380(COD) COM (2011)0804 C7-0460/2011 Valmistelija: Nikos Chrysogelos (Verts/ALE) PA PE v01-00 AM PE v01-00 AM PE v01-00 AM PE v01-00 DT PE v01-00 Vastaava: PECH Alain Cadec (PPE) PR PE v02-00 DT PE v01-00 Lausunto: BUDG, EMPL, ENVI, TRAN, REGI Lausuntoluonnoksen hyväksyminen Päätös: (Ks. äänestystulokset liitteessä VI.) Lausuntoluonnos hyväksyttiin näin muutettuna (äänin 49 puolesta, 4 vastaan ja 1 tyhjä). 14. Asbestiperäiset ammattitautiuhat ja mahdollisuudet kaiken olemassa olevan asbestin poistamiseen ENVI/7/ /2065(INI) Valmistelija: Sabine Wils (GUE/NGL) PA PE v01-00 AM PE v01-00 Vastaava: EMPL Stephen Hughes (S&D) PR PE v01-00 AM PE v01-00 Lausuntoluonnoksen hyväksyminen Päätös: (Ks. äänestystulokset liitteessä VII.) Lausuntoluonnos hyväksyttiin näin muutettuna (äänin 49 puolesta, 1 vastaan ja 0 tyhjää). 15. Ihmisille tarkoitettujen lääkkeiden hintojen sääntelytoimenpiteiden avoimuus ja kyseisten lääkkeiden sisällyttäminen yleisen sairausvakuutuksen korvausjärjestelmien piiriin ENVI/7/08978 ***I 2012/0035(COD) COM (2012)0084 C7-0056/2012 Esittelijä: Antonyia Parvanova (ALDE) PR PE v01-00 AM PE v02-00 PE v /110 PV\ doc

7 Vastaava: ENVI Lausunto: EMPL, ITRE, IMCO, JURI AM PE v01-00 Puheenvuorot: Matthias Groote, Antonyia Parvanova, Zofija Mazej Kukovič, Nessa Childers, Françoise Grossetête, Jolanta Emilia Hibner, Salvatore D'Acunto (yritys- ja teollisuustoiminnan pääosasto) 16. Direktiivin 2006/66/EY muuttaminen (johdottomissa työkaluissa käytettäviksi tarkoitettujen kadmiumia sisältävien paristojen ja akkujen markkinoille saattaminen) ENVI/7/09209 ***I 2012/0066(COD) COM (2012)0136 C7-0087/2012 Esittelijä: Vastaava: ENVI Lausunto: Vladko Todorov Panayotov (ALDE) PR PE v01-00 ITRE, JURI Puheenvuorot: Matthias Groote, Vladko Todorov Panayotov, Zofija Mazej Kukovič, Dan Jørgensen, Carl Schlyter, Åsa Westlund, Sophie Auconie, Julius Langendorff (ympäristöasioiden pääosasto) 17. Direktiivien 1999/4/EY, 2000/36/EY, 2001/111/EY, 2001/113/EY ja 2001/114/EY muuttaminen komissiolle siirrettävien valtuuksien osalta ENVI/7/09272 ***I 2012/0075(COD) COM (2012)0150 C7-0089/2012 Esittelijä: Matthias Groote (S&D) PR PE v01-00 Vastaava: ENVI Lausunto: DEVE, AGRI, JURI Puheenvuorot: Matthias Groote, Sophie Auconie, Britta Reimers, Linda McAvan, Hermanus Versteijlen (maatalouden ja maaseudun kehittämisen pääosasto) * Kokous keskeytettiin klo 18.02, ja sitä jatkettiin 29. marraskuuta klo 9.05 puheenjohtaja Matthias Grooten johdolla (koordinaattoreiden kokous). *** 18. Koordinaattoreiden kokous pidettiin suljetuin ovin 29. marraskuuta 2012 klo (Ks. kokouksen tulokset liitteessä I.) * Kokous keskeytettiin klo 10.04, ja sitä jatkettiin klo *** PV\ doc 7/110 PE v01-00

8 19. Keskustelu Euroopan kemikaaliviraston pääjohtajan Geert Dancetin kanssa ENVI/7/04319 Keskustelu Puheenvuorot: Matthias Groote, Geert Dancet (Euroopan kemikaaliviraston pääjohtaja), Satu Hassi, Richard Seeber, Jo Leinen, Holger Krahmer, Radvilė Morkūnaitė-Mikulėnienė, Tadeusz Cymański, Anne Laperrouze (Euroopan parlamentin edustaja hallintoneuvostossa), Graham Willmott (yritys- ja teollisuustoiminnan pääosasto) 20. ENVI-valiokunnan toimialaan liittyvät STOA-toimet: Luonnonvarojen kestävää hoitoa koskeva hanke ENVI/7/02356 Keskustelu Puheenvuorot: Matthias Groote, Csaba Sándor Tabajdi, Carl Schlyter, Sandra Berman (Bio Intelligence Service), Jana Polakova (Euroopan ympäristöpoliittinen instituutti), Salvatore Tatarella, Vittorio Prodi, Linda McAvan * Varapuheenjohtaja Carl Schlyter ryhtyi johtamaan kokousta klo *** * Puheenjohtaja Matthias Groote ryhtyi johtamaan kokousta klo *** 21. Linda McAvanin suullinen kysymys 2012/08 ilmanlaatudirektiivistä typpidioksidi ENVI/7/10952 Keskustelu komission edustajien kanssa CM PE V01-00 Puheenvuorot: Matthias Groote, Linda McAvan, Thomas Verheye (ympäristöasioiden pääosasto), Vittorio Prodi * Kokous keskeytettiin klo 12.25, ja sitä jatkettiin klo puheenjohtaja Matthias Grooten johdolla. *** 22. Jätteiden siirtojen valvonta ja tarkastaminen ENVI/7/10646 Keskustelu komission edustajien ja IMPEL-verkoston asiantuntijoiden kanssa Puheenvuorot: Matthias Groote, Julio Garcia Burgues (ympäristöasioiden pääosasto), Jacqueline McGlade (Euroopan ympäristökeskuksen pääjohtaja), Zofia Tucinska (IMPEL-verkoston puheenjohtaja), Katie Olley (IMPEL), Vittorio Prodi, Linda McAvan, Christa Klaß, Kathleen Van Brempt PE v /110 PV\ doc

9 23. Maailmanlaajuista rahastoa aidsin, tuberkuloosin ja malarian torjumiseksi koskeva rahoituskriisi ja sen vaikutukset EU-maihin, jotka ovat eniten alttiita tuberkuloosin multiresistentille kannalle, erityisesti Romaniaan ENVI/7/10042 Keskustelu komission edustajien ja tri Masoud Daran (WHO) kanssa Puheenvuorot: Matthias Groote, Masoud Dara (WHO), Jan Paehler (kehitys- ja yhteistyöpääosasto), Claudiu Ciprian Tănăsescu, Jolanta Emilia Hibner 24. Rehun ja elintarvikkeiden tuontia Japanista Fukushiman onnettomuuden jälkeen koskeva täytäntöönpanosäädös ENVI/7/05764 Keskustelu Puheenvuorot: Matthias Groote, Sandrine Bélier (Michèle Rivasin puolesta), Éric Poudelet (terveys- ja kuluttaja-asioiden pääosaston johtaja) 25. Seuraava kokous / Seuraavat kokoukset 17. joulukuuta 2012 klo 15:00 18:30 (Bryssel) 18. joulukuuta 2012 klo 9:00 12:30 (Bryssel) * Kokous päättyi klo *** PV\ doc 9/110 PE v01-00

10 ANNEX I EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT COMMITTEE ON THE ENVIRONMENT, PUBLIC HEALTH AND FOOD SAFETY CO-ORDINATORS' MEETING 29 November 2012, Room József Antall (JAN) 4Q2 RESULTS Present Mr Groote, Chairman Mr Liese, Co-coordinator of the EPP Group Mr Seeber, Co-coordinator of the EPP Group Ms McAvan, Coordinator of the S&D Group Mr Davies, Coordinator of the ALDE Group Ms Hassi, Coordinator of the Greens/EFA Group Ms Girling, replacing the Coordinator of the ECR Group Mr Rossi, Coordinator of the EFD Group 29 November 2012 Apologies Ms Rosbach, Coordinator of the ECR Group Ms Liotard, Coordinator of the GUE/NGL Group Also present Mr Gerbrandy, 1st Vice-Chair Reports Reports A.1. Fluorinated greenhouse gases ENVI/7/11159 ***I 2012/0305(COD) COM(2012)0643 C7-0370/2012 Responsible: ENVI Opinions: ITRE, IMCO [GA] Decision: Rapporteur to be nominated by the Greens/EFA. PE v /110 PV\ doc

11 1.a. Proposal for a Decision of the European Parliament and of the Council derogating temporarily from Directive 2003/87/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council establishing a scheme for greenhouse gas emission allowance trading within the Community 2012/0328(COD) - COM(2012) Note: Formal referral to ENVI pending Decision: Rapporteur to be nominated by the EPP Group A.1b. 7th Environmental Action Programme Proposal for a decision of the European Parliament and of the Council on a General Union Environment Action Programme to 2020 "Living well, within the limits of our planet" COM(2012)710 [(COD) n not yet available] [to be adopted on 29 November] Note: Formal referral to ENVI pending [ER] Decision: Rapporteur to be nominated by the EPP Group Opinions A.2. Amending Regulation (EC) No 273/2004 on drug precursors ENVI/7/10802 ***I 2012/0261(COD) COM(2012)0548 C7-0319/2012 Responsible: LIBE Opinions: INTA, ENVI, IMCO [ER] Decision: No opinion A.3. Special Report No 14/2012 (2011 discharge) - Implementation of EU hygiene legislation in slaughterhouses of countries that joined the EU since 2004 ENVI/7/ /2282(DEC) N7-0117/2012 C7-0368/2012 Responsible: CONT Esther de Lange (PPE) Opinions: ENVI, AGRI [ER] Decision: No opinion A.4. Special report No 15/2012 (discharge) - Management of conflict of interest in selected EU Agencies ENVI/7/ /2284(DEC) N7-0119/2012 C7-0373/2012 PV\ doc 11/110 PE v01-00

12 Responsible: CONT Opinions: ENVI, TRAN [ER] Decision: Invite representatives of the ECA for an exchange of views during a committee meeting. Further steps to be decided in the light of the outcome of that discussion. A.5. Advancing the EU s Maritime Transport and Tourism Policies ENVI/7/ /2297(INI) COM(2012)0491 Responsible: TRAN Opinions: EMPL, ENVI, ITRE, REGI, PECH [JV] Decision: No opinion A.6. The EU's External Aviation Policy - Addressing Future Challenges ENVI/7/ /2299(INI) COM(2012)0556 Responsible: TRAN Opinions: INTA, EMPL, ENVI, ITRE [JV] Decision: No opinion A.7. Authorisation for Member States to ratify, in the interests of the EU, the International Labour Organisation Convention of 1990 concerning Safety in the Use of Chemicals at Work (Convention No 170) ENVI/7/11300 *** 2012/0320(NLE) COM(2012)0677 [MF] Decision: No opinion PE v /110 PV\ doc

13 Documents received for information A.8. Report from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council on the communication on the safe use of chemicals COM(2012)0630 Responsible: ENVI Opinions: ITRE, IMCO [MF] Opinions: ITRE, IMCO Decision: Coordinators decided to invite the Commission for an exchange of views on the findings and conclusions of the report. A.9. Report from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council: The state of the European carbon market in 2012 COM(2012)0652 Responsible: ENVI Opinions: ECON, ITRE, JURI [JD] Decision: Oral Question (in plenary, Rule 115) to the Commission plus resolution (Rule 115(5)) A.10. Report from the Commission to the Council on the basis of Member States' reports on the implementation of the Council Recommendation (2009/C 151/01) on patient safety, including the prevention and control of healthcare associated infections COM(2012)0658 Responsible: ENVI Opinions: EMPL [ER] Decision: The coordinators decided to seek authorisation to draw up an own-initiative report and instructed the chair to write to the Conference of Committee Chairs accordingly. Decisions on items A.11., A.12. and A.13. to be taken jointly under item A.13. A.11. Report from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council on the Implementation of the Water Framework Directive (2000/60/EC): River Basin Management Plans COM(2012)0670 Responsible: ENVI Opinions: ITRE, REGI, AGRI [EI] PV\ doc 13/110 PE v01-00

14 A.12. Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions: Report on the Review of the European Water Scarcity and Droughts Policy COM(2012)0672 Responsible: ENVI Opinions: ECON, ITRE, REGI, AGRI A.13. Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions: A Blueprint to Safeguard Europe's Water Resources COM(2012)0673 Responsible: ENVI Opinions: ECON, ITRE, REGI, AGRI [EI] Decision: The coordinators decided to invite Commissioner Potocnik to give a presentation in the committee on the Blueprint and on future priority options for legislative action in the field. A.14. Report from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council on food and food ingredients treated with ionising radiation for the year 2011 COM(2012)0659 [GA] Decision: No action A.15. Report from the Commission to the Council and the European Parliament: Contribution of the Marine Strategy Framework Directive (2008/56/EC) to the implementation of existing obligations, commitments and initiatives of the Member States or the EU at EU or international level in the sphere of environmental protection in marine waters COM(2012)0662 [EI] Decision: No action * * * PE v /110 PV\ doc

15 B. INFORMATION ON OTHER ACTIVITIES B.1. Ongoing own-initiative reports (no more than 6 at any given time): 1 Only for information The following ordinary INI reports are currently progressing: On 1 March 2012, the coordinators decided to seek authorisation for the following new own-initiative report: "The protection of public health from endocrine disrupters" - Rapporteur: Ms WESTLUND, S&D - adoption in ENVI scheduled for 18 December 2012 Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council: Taking forward the Strategic Implementation Plan of the European Innovation Partnership on Active and Healthy Ageing - COM(2012) Rapporteur: Ms LIOTARD, GUE/NGL - adoption in ENVI scheduled for 18 December 2012 On 12 September 2012, the coordinators decided to seek authorisation for the following new own-initiative report "Eco-innovation - Jobs and Growth through environmental policy"- authorisation request pending - approved by CCC on 22 October On 12 September 2012, the coordinators decided to seek authorisation for the following new own-initiative report "Innovating for Sustainable Growth: A Bioeconomy for Europe" (COM(2012)0060)- Rapporteur Mr BARTOLOZZI, EPP; authorisation request pending - approved by CCC on 22 October Report from the Commission to the Council on the basis of Member States' reports on the implementation of the Council Recommendation (2009/C 151/01) on patient safety, including the prevention and control of healthcare associated infections - COM(2012) Coordinators' decision of 29 November 2012 B.2. Ongoing implementation reports Only for information Implementation report for 2012: "Improving the delivery of benefits from EU environment measures: building confidence through better knowledge and responsiveness" - Rapporteur Mr ROSSI, EFD - adoption in ENVI scheduled for 23 January 2013 (tbc) 1 The following INIs were adopted recently: Coordinators decided on 31 January 2012 to draw up an own-initiative report with the title: 'The Microbial Challenge Rising threats from Antimicrobial Resistance', authorised by CoP on 16 February rapporteur Ms ROSBACH, ECR Group - adopted in ENVI on 6 November 2012 "The environmental impacts of shale gas and shale oil extraction activities": authorisation by CoP 8 December rapporteur: Mr SONIK, EPP - adopted in ENVI on 19 September 2012 PV\ doc 15/110 PE v01-00

16 C. DECISIONS ON OTHER ISSUES C.0. The gradual introduction of the "emeeting" application Decision The Coordinators heard the Chairman who announced that the "emeeting" application for improved access to ENVI's meeting documents would be made available to interested Members and staff as from January. The purpose of this new tool was (a) to improve the availability of meeting papers and (b) to further reduce the waste of paper. Members and staff would be informed by about the next steps. C.1. Orientation debate on the application of new Rule 70 (negotiation of first reading agreements) Decision The Coordinators took note of the new wording of Rule 70 which shall enter into force on 10 December 2012 and reads as shown below. The Coordinators held an initial exchange of views and decided to hold an orientation debate during an extraordinary meeting in Strasbourg. * * * Rule Negotiations with the other institutions aimed at reaching an agreement in the course of a legislative procedure shall be conducted having regard to the Code of Conduct laid down by the Conference of Presidents. 2. Such negotiations shall not be entered into prior to the adoption by the committee responsible, on a case-by-case basis for every legislative procedure concerned and by a majority of its members, of a decision on the opening of negotiations. That decision shall determine the mandate and the composition of the negotiating team. Such decisions shall be notified to the President, who shall keep the Conference of Presidents informed on a regular basis. The mandate shall consist of a report adopted in committee and tabled for later consideration by Parliament. By way of exception, where the committee responsible considers it duly justified to enter into negotiations prior to the adoption of a report in committee, the mandate may consist of a set of amendments or a set of clearly defined objectives, priorities or orientations. PE v /110 PV\ doc

17 3. The negotiating team shall be led by the rapporteur and presided over by the Chair of the committee responsible or by a Vice-Chair designated by the Chair. It shall comprise at least the shadow rapporteurs from each political group. 4. Any document intended to be discussed in a meeting with the Council and the Commission ( trilogue ) shall take the form of a document indicating the respective positions of the institutions involved and possible compromise solutions and shall be circulated to the negotiating team at least 48 hours, or in cases of urgency at least 24 hours, in advance of the trilogue in question. After each trilogue the negotiating team shall report back to the following meeting of the committee responsible. Documents reflecting the outcome of the last trilogue shall be made available to the committee. Where it is not feasible to convene a meeting of the committee in a timely manner, the negotiating team shall report back to the Chair, the shadow rapporteurs and the coordinators of the committee, as appropriate. The committee responsible may update the mandate in the light of the progress of the negotiations. 5. If the negotiations lead to a compromise, the committee responsible shall be informed without delay. The agreed text shall be submitted to the committee responsible for consideration. If approved by a vote in committee, the agreed text shall be tabled for consideration by Parliament in the appropriate form, including compromise amendments. It may be presented as a consolidated text provided that it clearly displays the modifications to the proposal for a legislative act under consideration. 6. Where the procedure involves associated committees or joint committee meetings, Rules 50 and 51 shall apply to the decision on the opening of negotiations and to the conduct of such negotiations. In the event of disagreement between the committees concerned, the modalities for the opening of negotiations and the conduct of such negotiations shall be determined by the Chair of the Conference of Committee Chairs in accordance with the principles set out in those Rules. * * * PV\ doc 17/110 PE v01-00

18 C.2. Nomination of additional speakers for hearing on tobacco products [ER] The papers for the meeting include list of proposed experts from different political groups. Decision The Coordinators recalled that the following 5 speakers had already been invited Ms Martina Pötschke-Langer Mr David Hammond Ms Jean King Ms Florence Berteletti Kemp Mr Brendan Nelson The Coordinators decided to invite the following two additional speakers: Mr James Reilly - Irish Minister for Health Ms Antonella Pederiva, Secretary-General of the Confederation of European Community Cigarette Manufacturers (CECCM) 1 The coordinators noted that the Greens/EFA opposed the invitation to Ms Pederiva. The Coordinators agreed to decide on the outstanding eighth invitation at their next meeting. 1 see in particular Conclusion 20: "20. In setting and implementing public health policies with respect to tobacco control, any necessary interaction with the tobacco industry should be carried out by Parties in such a way as to avoid the creation of any perception of a real or potential partnership or cooperation resulting from or on account of such interaction. In the event the tobacco industry engages in any conduct that may create such a perception, Parties should act to prevent or correct this perception. Recommendations 2.1 Parties should interact with the tobacco industry only when and to the extent strictly necessary to enable them to effectively regulate the tobacco industry and tobacco products. 2.2 Where interactions with the tobacco industry are necessary, Parties should ensure that such interactions are conducted transparently. Whenever possible, interactions should be conducted in public, for example through public hearings, public notice of interactions, disclosure of records of such interactions to the public." PE v /110 PV\ doc

19 C.3. Cooperation with other committees - conflicts of competence and requests for Rule 50 and Rule The Coordinators were informed that a solution as to the application of Rule 50 in relation to CO2 emissions from cars and CO2 emissions from vans had been agreed between the respective rapporteurs. 2. The Coordinators were informed that AGRI challenged the attribution of the revision of the Honey Directive to ENVI. A letter from Mr Groote to Mr Lehne details the grounds for ENVI's objection to AGRI's request. 3. The papers for the meeting included a letter from Ms Sartori, Chair of the ITRE Committee, to Mr Lehne on ITRE's request for the application of Rule 51 in relation to the ILUC proposal. Decision The coordinators took note of the above information. C.4. Information from CCC on the publication of names of shadow rapporteurs The papers for the meeting included an message dated 7 November 2012 from Klaus- Heiner Lehne, Chairman of the Conference of Committee Chairs: Decision The Coordinators took note of the information that the names of shadow-rapporteurs would as a rule appear on their respective Member's notice - unless the concerned Member would inform the committee secretariat, preferably via his/her political group, and at anytime of the procedure, that he/she would object to the publication on his individual page on the EP Internet of his role as shadow-rapporteur in a particular file. C.5. EU-Russia on Climate Change, December, Strasburg [JV] The papers for the meeting included letter from Mr Fleckenstein, Chair of EU-Russia Parliamentary Cooperation Committee, on EU-Russia Climate Change. Decision The Coordinators invited Mr Liese (rapporteur for the inclusion of aviation into the ETS) to represent the ENVI committee and to address the Russian parliamentarians. PV\ doc 19/110 PE v01-00

20 C.6. Request from Mr Davies to invite Vice-President Tajani on Mobile air conditioning in motor vehicles [GA] Decision The Coordinators decided to invite Vice-President Tajani to the ENVI Committee to explain the situation. C.7. Request by Mr Liese to approve Health Working Group timetable [ER] HEALTH WORKING GROUP TIMETABLE Meetings 2013 Wednesday, 20 February, :45 Wednesday, 24 April, :45 Wednesday, 19 June, :45 Wednesday, 18 September, :45 Wednesday, 9 October, :45 Advanced Therapy Medicinal Products Newborn Infants Childhood Vaccination/Immunisation Effectiveness of medicines and therapies Transfats Decision The Coordinators approved the timetable as shown above, while objecting to the workshop on 'EFSA and its independence' which was not covered by the HWG's mandate. noted that requests for the authorisation of the individual meetings would be submitted in due course (specific decisions on the use of ENVI's expertise budget). C.8. Request by Ms McAvan for oral question on spread of Chalara Fraxinea [ZL] Decision The Coordinators approve the above Oral Question (in committee, Rule 197) to the Commission in principle and invited Ms McAvan to provide them with an updated wording. PE v /110 PV\ doc

21 C.9. Two request from Ms Hassi and Mr Schlyter concerning Schlyter report on ship recycling) [MF] Decision: 1. The Coordinators decided to request a Legal Opinion on Article 29 (exclusion of ships from waste shipment regulation) of the Commission proposal. 2. The Coordinators decided to request an impact assessment on Mr Schlyter's Amendment 44 (recycling levy). C.10. Request by Ms Lepage and Mr Davies for workshop on the amendment of the Fuel Quality Directive and of the Renewable Energy Directive [EI] Decision The Coordinators decided to request a workshop on the amendment of the Fuel Quality Directive and of the Renewable Energy Directive (so-called ILUC proposal). C.11. Request by Mr Liese and Mr Seeber to invite Mr Kessler to the ENVI Committee [ER] Decision The Coordinators decided to invite Mr Kessler, Director-General of OLAF, to an exchange of views on the circumstances of Mr Dalli's resignation in the ENVI Committee. C.12. EP Representatives on EMA Management Board - procedure [NK] The papers for the meeting included letter from Kent Woods to President Schulz on expiry of term of current EP representatives. Decision The Coordinators decided to propose the renewal of the mandates of Prof Lemmer and Prof Nisticò for the next term of 3 years and instructed the Chairman to inform the President of the European Parliament of this proposal. Note: Final decision on appointment to be taken by the Conference of Presidents. PV\ doc 21/110 PE v01-00

22 * * * D. DOCUMENTS FOR INFORMATION 1) Letter of 9 November 2012 from Secretary General Klaus Welle to Mr Groote on paper reduction in ENVI. PE v /110 PV\ doc

23 ANNEX II VOTING LIST on the draft Council regulation.../ concerning the use of lactic acid to reduce microbiological surface contamination on bovine carcases Rule 88(2) and (4)(b) of the Rules of Procedure Error! Reference source not found. by Linda McAvan, Dagmar Roth-Behrendt, Bas Eickhout, Carl Schlyter and Bart Staes IN FAVOUR AGAINST ABSTENTIONS DRAFT MOTION FOR RESOLUTION: PV\ doc 23/110 PE v01-00

24 ANNEX III VOTING LIST on the classification, packaging and labelling of dangerous substances PR PE489.01v AM - PE v01-00 Rapporteur: Eija-Riitta Korhola Concerned text Article 20 - paragraph 5 AM Tabled by Comments/ remarks 1 Satu Hassi Vote IN FAVOUR AGAINST ABSTENTION DRAFT REPORT AS AMENDED DRAFT LEGISLATIVE RESOLUTION PE v /110 PV\ doc

25 ANNEX IV VOTING LIST on the Union Civil Protection Mechanism PR - PE v01-00 AM PE v03-00 and PE v03-00 AD - DEVE/PE , REGI/PE , BUDG/PE , AFET/PE Rapporteur: Elisabetta Gardini Provision AM Author Remarks Rapp. Vote Article 1 - General objectives and subject matter Article 1 paragraph 1 AM 65 Rosbach /25/0 AM 68 Hassi + + AM 66 Rossi Falls if AM 65 is adopted. AM 67 Sousa REGI 22 REGI Falls if AM 65 is adopted. - F Article 1 paragraph 2 AM 71 Juvin, Franco Split vote requested by Greens/EFA: - 1st part: the whole text without replacing "environmental" by "industrial"; - 2nd part: those words. - AM 69 Rosbach + - PV\ doc 25/110 PE v01-00

26 Provision AM Author Remarks Rapp. Vote REGI 23 REGI Falls if AM 69 is adopted (covered). + - AM 70 Rossi /20/1 Article 1 paragraph 3 AM 75 Groote + + Oral AM Sommer The Union intervention enhances prevention, preparedness and response capacity of Member States to face major disasters minimising human and material loss. In such cases the primary national responsibility shall be complemented by EU measures when the Member State concerned is unable to deal with the situation. F Note to the Chair: decide on the admissibility of the oral amendment. The oral amendment falls if AM 75 is adopted. AM 72 Rosbach Falls if AM 75 or the oral amendment is adopted. AM 73 Rossi Falls is AM 75 or 72 or the oral amendment is adopted. - F AM 74 Estrela + + AFET 6 AFET If AM 75 or the oral amendment is adopted, the part "in full compliance with... and proportionality" falls Vote on the rest of the text /24/0 PE v /110 PV\ doc

27 Provision AM Author Remarks Rapp. Vote Article 1 paragraph 3 a AFET 7 AFET Article 1 paragraph 5 AM 77 Sommer, Florenz /28/0 AM 76 Hassi REGI 24 REGI + + REGI 25 REGI Falls if AM 77 is adopted (covered) /22/0 Article 1 paragraph 6 Article 1 paragraph 7 AM 78 Rossi REGI 26 REGI Article 1 a AM 79 Rossi The amendment makes participation in the Mechanism voluntary. If AM 79 is adopted, the following amendments are deemed fully or partially adopted: 43, 63, 111, 160, 161, 162, 195, 200, 201, 203, 207, 208, 214, 215, 216, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 223, 224, 225, 227. If AM 79 is rejected, those amendments are deemed fully or partially rejected. Article 2 Scope Article 2 paragraph 1 AM 80 Hassi - PV\ doc 27/110 PE v01-00

28 Provision AM Author Remarks Rapp. Vote Article 2 paragraph 2 AM 81 Rosbach AM 82 Rossi Falls if AM 81 is adopted. + + Article 2 paragraph 2 a AM 83 Gutiérrez- Cortines If rejected, AM 91 falls. + - Article 2 paragraph 3 AM 84 Juvin, Ponga /28/0 REGI 27 REGI 1/56/0 Article 3 - Specific objectives Article 3 paragraph 1 intro Article 3 paragraph 1 point a Article 3 paragraph 1 point b AM 86 Rossi AM 85 Rosbach Falls if AM 86 is adopted. REGI 28 REGI + + AM 88 Rossi AM 89 Sommer, Florenz Falls if AM 88 is adopted /26/0 AM 87 Rosbach Falls if AM 88 or 89 is adopted. + + Article 3 paragraph 1 point c AM 90 Rosbach Article 3 paragraph 1 AM 91 Gutiérrez- Cortines Falls if AM 83 is rejected. PE v /110 PV\ doc

29 Provision AM Author Remarks Rapp. Vote point c a BUDG 14 BUDG Vote as a separate point. + + Article 3 paragraph 2 AM 92 Sommer, Florenz Deletion If adopted, all amendments to Article 3(2) fall. Article 3 paragraph 2 intro Article 3 paragraph 2 point a AFET 8 AFET Falls if AM 92 is adopted. AM 93 Juvin Falls if AM 92 is adopted. + + AM 94 Rosbach Falls if AM 92 is adopted. AM 8 AM 95 Rapporteur Sousa Identical in substance. Falls if AM 92 is adopted. + + AM 96 AFET 9 Cliveti, Sârbu AFET Article 3 paragraph 2 point b Article 3 paragraph 2 point c AM 98 Estrela Falls if AM 92 is adopted. + + AM 97 Rossi Falls if AM 92 is adopted. REGI 29 REGI Falls if AM 92 is adopted /29/0 Article 4 Definitions Article 4 point 1 AM 99 Rossi If rejected, AM 103 falls. AM 100 Juvin Falls if AM 99 is adopted. If rejected, AM 104 falls. DEVE 5 DEVE Falls if AM 99 or 100 is adopted. + + PV\ doc 29/110 PE v01-00

30 Provision AM Author Remarks Rapp. Vote AM 102 Sommer, Florenz Falls if any of the above AMs is adopted. - F If rejected, AM 107 falls. AM 101 Koumoutsakos If rejected, AM 109 falls. + + Article 4 point 2 AM 103 Rossi Falls if AM 99 is rejected. AM 104 Juvin Falls if AM 100 is rejected. - F Falls if AM 103 is adopted. AM 107 Sommer, Florenz Falls if AM 102 is rejected. Falls if AM 103 or 104 is adopted. - F REGI 30 REGI Falls if any of the above AMs is adopted. AM 105 Poc First part ("over a wide area") falls if any of the above AMs is adopted. In that case vote on the rest of the text. AM 106 Cliveti, Sârbu Falls if the 2nd part of AM 105 is adopted (covered). + - Article 4 point 4 Article 4 point 5 Article 4 point 6 AM 108 Rosbach + - AM 109 Koumoutsakos Falls if AM 101 is rejected /19/0 AM 110 Rosbach + - Article 4 point 6 a AM 111 Rossi Do not vote. Deemed adopted or rejected depending on the result of the vote on AM PE v /110 PV\ doc

31 Provision AM Author Remarks Rapp. Vote Article 4 point 9 AM 112 Rosbach + - AM 113 Sousa + + REGI 31 REGI + + Article 4 point 10 AM 9 Rapporteur + + Article 4 - point 11 a AM 114 Gutiérrez- Cortines /36/0 Article 5 - Prevention actions Article 5 point a REGI 33 REGI + + AM 115 Cliveti, Sârbu AM 10 Rapporteur Falls if REGI 33 is adopted (covered). REGI 32 REGI + + Article 5 point b Article 5 point c AM 11 Rapporteur + + AM 116 Rosbach /33/0 AM 117 Rossi AM 118 Hassi + + AM 119 Estrela + + AM 120 Poc + + PV\ doc 31/110 PE v01-00

32 Provision AM Author Remarks Rapp. Vote Article 5 point d CONS 1 / Part 1 Consolidated amendment by EPP, S&D, ALDE, Greens/EFA, GUE/NGL + + If adopted, the following amendments fall: AM 12, AM , REGI AM 121 Rosbach Falls if CONS 1 / Part 1 is adopted. AM 122 Sousa Falls if CONS 1 / Part 1 is adopted. REGI 35 REGI Falls if CONS 1 / Part 1 is adopted. - F Falls if AM 122 is adopted (covered). AM 12 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 1 / Part 1 is adopted. Falls if AM 122 or REGI 35 is adopted (covered). AM 123 Estrela Falls if CONS 1 / Part 1 is adopted. REGI 34 REGI Falls if CONS 1 / Part 1 is adopted. Falls if AM 122 is adopted (covered). Article 5 point e REGI 36 REGI + + REGI 37 REGI + + Article 5 - point f BUDG 15 BUDG Article 5 point f a REGI 38 REGI + + PE v /110 PV\ doc

33 Provision AM Author Remarks Rapp. Vote Article 5 point g AM 124 Sommer, Florenz AM 125 Rossi Falls if AM 124 is adopted. If AM 79 is rejected, the reference to "participating countries" is to be replaced by "Member States". Article 5 point g a REGI 39 REGI Article 6 - Risk management plans Article 6 CONS 1 / Part 2 Consolidated amendment by EPP, S&D, ALDE, Greens/EFA, GUE/NGL If adopted, the following amendments fall: AM , REGI 40-43, BUDG 16-17, AFET Article 6 AM 126 Krahmer, Meissner Falls if CONS 1 / Part 2 is adopted. Deletion If adopted, all amendments to Article 6 fall. - F Article 6 paragraph 1 AM 127 Rosbach Falls if CONS 1 / Part 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 126 is adopted. If rejected, AM 139 as well as the reference to the "description of risk management capabilities" in AM 131 fall. - F AM 128 Rossi Falls if CONS 1 / Part 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 126 or 127 is adopted. - F PV\ doc 33/110 PE v01-00

34 Provision AM Author Remarks Rapp. Vote AM 129 Koumoutsakos, Skylakakis Falls if CONS 1 / Part 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 126, 127 or 128 is adopted. REGI 40 REGI Falls if CONS 1 / Part 2 is adopted. - F Falls if AM 126 is adopted. AFET 10 AFET Falls if CONS 1, Part 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 126 is adopted. Article 6 paragraph 2 AM 131 Rosbach Falls if CONS 1, Part 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 126 is adopted. Reference to the "description of their risk management capabilities" falls if AM 127 is rejected. Vote on the rest of the amendment. - F REGI 41 REGI Falls if CONS 1 / Part 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 126 is adopted. AM 132 Hassi Falls if CONS 1 / Part 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 126 is adopted. REGI 42 REGI Falls if CONS 1 / Part 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 126 is adopted. AM 133 Estrela Falls if CONS 1 / Part 2 is adopted. AM 135 Poc PE v /110 PV\ doc

35 Provision AM Author Remarks Rapp. Vote AM 136 Cliveti, Sârbu Identical. Falls if AM 126 is adopted. Falls if REGI 41 is adopted (covered). BUDG 16 BUDG Falls if CONS 1 / Part 2 is adopted. - F Falls if AM 126 is adopted. AM 134 Rossi Falls if CONS 1 / Part 2 is adopted. - F Falls if AM 126 is adopted. Article 6 paragraph 2 a AM 137 Taylor Falls if CONS 1 / Part 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 126 is adopted. AM 138 Rossi Falls if CONS 1 / Part 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 126 is adopted. - F Article 6 paragraph 3 REGI 43 REGI Falls if CONS 1 / Part 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 126 is adopted. Deletion If adopted, all amendments to Article 6(3) fall. - F AM 142 Poc Falls if CONS 1 / Part 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 126 or REGI 43 is adopted. PV\ doc 35/110 PE v01-00

36 Provision AM Author Remarks Rapp. Vote AM 140 Estrela Falls if CONS 1 / Part 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 126 or REGI 43 is adopted. Falls if AM 142 is adopted (covered). AM 130 Poc Falls if CONS 1 / Part 2 is adopted. - F Falls if AM 126 or REGI 43 is adopted. Otherwise vote on the part "immediately following their drafting" as addition to Article 6(3). AM 139 Rosbach Falls if CONS 1 / Part 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 126 or REGI 43 is adopted. Falls if AM 127 is rejected. AM 141 Rossi Falls if CONS 1 / Part 2 is adopted. - F Falls if AM 126 or REGI 43 is adopted. Article 6 paragraph 3 a AM 143 Poc Falls if CONS 1 / Part 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 126 is adopted. - F PE v /110 PV\ doc

37 Provision AM Author Remarks Rapp. Vote BUDG 17 BUDG Falls if CONS 1 / Part 2 is adopted. Falls if any of these AMs is adopted: AM 126, 142, 140 or REGI 43. Article 7 - General preparedness actions of the Commission Article 7 AM 144 Krahmer, Meissner Deletion If adopted, all amendments tabled to Article 7 fall, and all references to the ERC and CECIS are to be deleted from the text. Article 7 point a AM 146 Poc Falls if AM 144 is adopted. REGI 44 REGI Identical. + + AFET 11 AFET Falls if AM 144 is adopted. Falls if AM 146 is adopted (covered). AM 145 Rosbach Falls if AM 144 is adopted. Article 7 point b Article 7 point c Article 7 point d intro AM 147 Rosbach Falls if AM 144 is adopted. AFET 12 AFET Falls if AM 144 is adopted. + + REGI 45 REGI Falls if AM 144 is adopted. AFET 13 AFET Falls if AM 144 is adopted. + + AM 148 Rossi Falls if AM 144 is adopted. PV\ doc 37/110 PE v01-00

38 Provision AM Author Remarks Rapp. Vote Article 7 point d indent 1 Article 7 point d indent 2 REGI 46 REGI Falls if AM 144 is adopted. + + AM 149 Rosbach Falls if AM 144 is adopted. REGI 47 REGI Falls if AM 144 is adopted. + + AFET 14 AFET Falls if AM 144 is adopted. Article 7 point e AM 150 Rossi Falls if AM 144 is adopted. AM 151 Rosbach Falls if AM 144 is adopted. + + REGI 48 REGI Falls if AM 144 is adopted. Article 7 point f AM 152 AM 153 Rosbach Sommer, Florenz Identical. Falls if AM 144 is adopted. AM 154 Juvin, Ponga Falls if AM 144 or AM 152/153 is adopted. Article 7 point f a AM 156 Hibner Falls if AM 144 is adopted. + + AM 15 Rapporteur Falls if AM 144 is adopted. + + Falls if AM 156 is adopted (covered). AM 155 Estrela Falls if AM 144 is adopted. + + Vote as a separate point. Article 7 point g AM 157 AM 158 Rosbach Sommer, Florenz Identical. Falls if AM 144 is adopted. PE v /110 PV\ doc

39 Provision AM Author Remarks Rapp. Vote AM 159 Juvin Do not vote. Does not affect all linguistic versions. + Article 7 paragraph 1 a Article 7 paragraph 1 b AM 13 Rapporteur Falls if AM 144 is adopted. + + AM 14 Rapporteur Falls if AM 144 is adopted. + + Article 8 Modules Article 8 paragraph 1 AM 16 Rapporteur + + AM 160 Rossi Do not vote. Deemed adopted or rejected depending on the result of the vote on AM 79. Article 8 paragraph 2 subparagraph 1 AM 161 Rossi Do not vote. Deemed adopted or rejected depending on the result of the vote on AM 79. Article 8 paragraph 3 a AM 17 Rapporteur + + Article 9 - General preparedness actions of the Member States Article 9 title AM 162 Rossi Do not vote. Deemed adopted or rejected depending on the result of the vote on AM 79. Article 9 paragraph 2 AM 163 Rossi Article 9 paragraph 2 a AM 164 Rossi If AM 79 is rejected, "participating countries" is replaced by "Member States". PV\ doc 39/110 PE v01-00

40 Provision AM Author Remarks Rapp. Vote Article 9 paragraph 3 Article 9 paragraph 6 Article 9 paragraph 7 Article 9 paragraph 8 a AM 165 Groote + + AM 166 Rosbach AM 18 Rapporteur + + AM 19 Rapporteur + + Article 9 a AM 167 Sommer, Florenz W W Article 10 - Planning of operations Article 10 paragraph 1 intro Article 10 paragraph 1 point a Article 10 paragraph 1 point b Article 10 paragraph 1 point b a AM 168 Rosbach /29/0 AM 169 Rosbach + - AM 170 Hassi Falls if AM 169 is adopted. REGI 49 REGI + + AM 171 Taylor - + Article 10 paragraph 2 DEVE 6 DEVE Do not vote. Deemed adopted (DEVE's exclusive competence under Rule 50). + + AM 172 Rosbach Falls (the provision is within DEVE's exclusive competence). PE v /110 PV\ doc

41 Provision AM Author Remarks Rapp. Vote REGI 50 REGI Falls (the provision is within DEVE's exclusive competence) - F. Article 11 - European Emergency Response Capacity Article 11 title Article 11 paragraph 1 Article 11 paragraph 3 AM 173 Rosbach AM 174 Rosbach AM 175 Groote + + AM 20 Rapporteur + + AFET 15 AFET AM 176 Cliveti, Sârbu Falls if AFET 15 is adopted. + + Article 11 paragraph 4 Article 11 paragraph 4 a Article 11 paragraph 4 b AM 177 Estrela + + AFET 16 AFET + + AM 21 Rapporteur + + AM 22 Rapporteur + + Article 11 paragraph 6 AFET 17 AFET AM 179 Sommer, Florenz Falls if AFET 17 is adopted /31/0 PV\ doc 41/110 PE v01-00

42 Provision AM Author Remarks Rapp. Vote AM 180 Taylor Falls if AFET 17 is adopted. + + BUDG 18 BUDG AM 178 Rossi If AM 79 is rejected, "participating countries" is replaced by "Member States". Article 11 paragraph 6 subparagraph 1 a Article 11 paragraph 7 Article 11 paragraph 8 AM 181 Rossi REGI 51 REGI AM 182 Rossi DEVE 7 DEVE Falls if AM 182 is adopted. Article 12 - Addressing capacity gaps Article 12 CONS 2 Consolidated amendment by EPP, S&D, ALDE, Greens/EFA, GUE/NGL, EFD + + If adopted, the following amendments fall: AM 23-25, AM , BUDG 19, REGI 52, AFET Article 12 AM 183 Krahmer, Meissner Falls if CONS 2 is adopted. Deletion If adopted, all amendments tabled to Article 12 fall. - F Article 12 paragraph 1 AM 184 Sommer, Florenz Falls if CONS 2 is adopted. - F PE v /110 PV\ doc

43 Provision AM Author Remarks Rapp. Vote Article 12 paragraph 2 AM 185 Sommer, Florenz Falls if AM 183 is adopted. Vote in block (one concept). If AM 185 is adopted, all amendments tabled to Article 12(2) fall. Article 12 paragraph 1 AFET 18 AFET Falls if CONS 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 183 or 184 is adopted. - F Article 12 paragraph 2 introductory part AFET 19 AFET Falls if CONS 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 183 or 185 is adopted. AM 186 Rosbach Falls if CONS 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 183 or 185 is adopted. Falls if AFET 19 is adopted (covered). Article 12 paragraph 2 point b AM 188 Estrela Falls if CONS 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 183 or 185 is adopted. BUDG 19 BUDG Falls if CONS 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 183 or 185 is adopted. Falls if AM 188 is adopted (covered). AM 187 Rosbach Falls if CONS 2 is adopted. - F Falls if AM 183 or 185 is adopted. Article 12 paragraph 2 a AFET 20 AFET Falls if CONS 2 is adopted. - F PV\ doc 43/110 PE v01-00

44 Provision AM Author Remarks Rapp. Vote Article 12 paragraph 2 point b a REGI 52 REGI Falls if CONS 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 183 or 185 is adopted. Article 12 paragraph 3 AFET 21 AFET Falls if CONS 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 183 is adopted. Article 12 paragraph 4 AM 23 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 183 is adopted. AM 189 Rossi Falls if CONS 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 183 is adopted. If AM 79 is rejected, "participating countries" is replaced by "Member States". - F AFET 22 AFET Falls if CONS 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 183 is adopted. - F Article 12 paragraph 4 a AM 190 Taylor Falls if CONS 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 183 is adopted. Article 12 paragraph 5 AM 191 Rossi Falls if CONS 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 183 is adopted. - F AFET 23 AFET Falls if CONS 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 183 or 191 is adopted. Article 12 paragraph 6 AFET 24 AFET Falls if CONS 2 is adopted. Falls if AM 183 is adopted. - F Article 12 paragraph 7 AM 24 Rapporteur Falls if CONS 2 is adopted. PE v /110 PV\ doc